SONG OF PROTEST (Famous Are the Flowers)
Every Hawaiian song is a poem, built with words that come from a feeling heart. The songs are called “mele” and one who writes them is called a “haku mele,” one who braids words and music together that allows one heart to touch another.
Just as there are songs that celebrate beauty, love, and all of the other feel-good parts of life and songs that honor respected leaders and foster pride in a people, there are also songs that express anger, sorrow, pain, and resistance. (They, too, are a part of life, after all, and Hawaiian songs and poems do express all of life.)
Songs of protest, mele ku’e, are a traditional part of the repertoire of Hawaiian music. The practice continues to this very day.
A NATIONAL TREASURE
One of the more beautiful projects in recent years, was Project Kuleana, which was conceived and put together by Sean Naleimaile, Kihei Nahalea and Kamakoa Lindsey-Asing in collaboration with Kamehameha Publishing and 4 Miles LLC.
This video, which was published in 2013, took more than two years to put together. It has been shared thousands of times online (and otherwise) since then.
More than two dozen island performing artists, including greats like the late Palani Vaughn and Ernie Cruz, Jr., and shining talents like Kealii Reichel, Brother Noland Conjugacion and many others volunteered their time and their music at a special place of their choosing to record a couple of songs – one in Hawaiian and the other in English.
The first song to be published for the Project was a song that holds a special place in the hearts of the native people of the islands.
The song has had various names, including “The Stone-Eating Song” (Mele ‘Ai Pohaku), “The Patriot’s Song” (Mele Aloha ‘Aina), A Lei for Those Who Love the Land” (He Lei no ka Poe Aloha ‘Aina) and “Famous are the Children” (Kaulana Na Pua).
(The video has since been incorporated into the educational materials for the Kamehameha Schools, the school that was established by Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop, for her people.)
BIRTH OF A SONG
The song was written in 1893 by one of Queen Liliuokalani’s ladies-in-waiting, Ellen Kekoaohiwaikalani Wright Pendergast during the aftermath of the 1893 coup-d’etat that resulted in the overthrow of the Hawaiian monarchy. Pendergast was already a renowned poet and song-weaver at the time.
It’s important to note that Kaulana Na Pua was only one of Pendergast’s protest songs about the overthrow. There were at least ten others written by her within four months of the overturning of the Hawaiian kingdom’s government.
During that same time as well other poets – native and non-native — produced at least forty patriotic and protest songs.
The story’s been told before. As U.S. president Grover Cleveland explained in his report of that year to the Congress:
“And so it happened that on the 16th day of January, 1893, between four and five o’clock in the afternoon, a detachment of marines from the United States Steamer Boston, with two pieces of artillery, landed at Honolulu. The men, upwards of 160 in all, were supplied with double cartridge belts filled with ammunition and with haversacks and canteens, and were accompanied by a hospital corps with stretchers and medical supplies. This military demonstration upon the soil of Honolulu was of itself an act of war. . .”
The Provisional Government, which was composed primarily of American businessmen who lived in the islands, was an unpopular ruling minority. When their plan for immediate annexation to America was thwarted by a U. S. Presidential investigation, the country remained under martial law .
In the months following the overthrow, the protests against the Provisional Government among the citizenry, both Hawaiian and non-Hawaiian, continued. For the most part, the protests were non-violent acts of resistance as the people followed their queen’s wishes and example.
Two newspapers of the time, “Hawaii Holomua” and “The Daily Bulletin” describe the protest in articles entitled, “A Solemn Protest,” and “Protest of the People.”
The jittery “Republic of Hawaii” banned all large gatherings and kept the city of Honolulu under constant surveillance. To outwit them, the loyalists devised a secret method of passing along information by means of newly composed songs of words with kaona, double-meanings.
The efforts of the infant government to hold onto the power they had seized included threats to newspaper editors and requiring all members of government – from cabinet ministers to teachers, mail-carriers and policemen – to take an oath of allegiance and deny the right of their Queen to rule them. Those who chose to stay loyal to their Queen were told they would lose their jobs.
Despite these threats, many government employees refused to sign the oaths that forswore their loyalty to the queen. Among them were all but two of the members of the Royal Hawaiian Band, which had been established in 1936.
Band leaders asked Pendergast to write a mele ku’e for them that would express their passionate conviction and support of the Queen as well as their distress. She penned the mele at a table set in the family rose gardens.
The poem’s five verses of four lines each have been translated into English at various times. One of the more recent examples is on Wikipedia:
Famous are the children of Hawaiʻi
Ever loyal to the land
When the evil-hearted messenger comes
With his greedy document of extortion
Hawaiʻi, land of Keawe answers
The bays of Piʻilani help
Kauaʻi of Mano lends support
All are united by the sands of Kākuhihewa
Do not fix a signature
To the paper of the enemy
With its sin of annexation
And sale of the civil rights of the people
We do not value
The government’s hills of money
We are satisfied with the rocks
The wondrous food of the land
We support Liliʻuokalani
Who has won the rights of the land
The story is told
Of the people who love the land
[The lyrics mention four sacred chiefs that ruled the major islands of the Hawaiian chain at other times in the kingdom’s history: Keawe of the Big Island of Hawaii, Pi’ilani of Maui, Mano of Kaua’i and Kakuhihewa of Oahu.]
Some people say that the original music for the piece was written by a band-leader, J.S. Libornio. According to one story, the song was presented as a warrior’s chant and the dance that accompanied it was full of aggressive moves and attitude. The musical notations for this version of the song were lost in the intervening years.
After World War II, when there was a revival of interest in traditional Hawaiian music, Pendergast’s daughter Eleanor took the lyrics to a professional songwriter Maddy K. N. Lam and asked that she write music for it. This was subsequently published and copyrighted and has become the standard version of the song.
To my (somewhat irreverent, modern) mind, this seems like taking a slam poem and turning it into a waltz…but, that’s just me. It is the way the song has been sung ever since.
ON WITH THE STORY….
The queen’s supporters sang the song and it spread, as folk songs do. It was printed in several Hawaiian-language newspapers and became even more popular.
By the fall of that year there was a massive petition drive encompassing the islands that supported Queen Lili’uokalani and in opposition of the annexation. These documents, known as the Palapala Hoopii Kue Hoohui Aina (Petition Protesting Annexation), were presented to the U.S. Congress as proof that the great majority of Hawaii’s citizens opposed the annexation of Hawaii to the United States.
For a number of reasons, the petition did not stop the annexation nor was the country returned to the Queen and her people. The world marched on and for many years the song remained as a poignant reminder of the sorrow and the sense of loss among those who loved the world as it had been.
During the first half of the 20th century, the song was treated with the utmost reverence and respect one shows to spiritual and sacred songs. It was never included among the repertoire of popular Hawaiian dances.
The song was very rarely danced except on special occasions and only when the audience could understand the full significance of the words and language that was used.
The premier hula dancer and teacher of the time, ‘Iolani Luahine, who was born in 1915 and learned the art of hula through her aunt Keahi, a royal dancer in the courts of King Kalakaua and Queen Lili’uokalani, was quite firm that the song should be performed by a master hula dancer as a solemn standing hula. (Luahine died in 1978, a revered icon of the dance.)
The dancers who performed the hula for Kaulana Na Pua back then customarily wore black holoku (a loose, seamed dress with a train) and only their hands were used to interpret the meaning of the words.
It was an especially powerful way to present the song. When danced in this way, every word and each thought contained in the song could be imbued with emotion and power. Nothing was allowed to distract from the focus on the words. This was why it was felt that only a master dancer could perform the dance properly.
THE STORY CONTINUES
But the times they were a-changing. The hostility softened in time and was mitigated by the inclusion of native Hawaiians in positions of political power in the Territory of Hawaii.
In the interest of keeping the song alive, a number of influential kumu hula, hula masters, led the way in choreographing dances for their schools that included feet that moved to the music.
In the early 1960s Noelani Mahoe and the Leo Nahenahe Singers included “Kaulana Na Pua” in their album Folksongs of Hawai’i. It was probably the first time the song had been exposed to such a broad audience of people. (I remember the first time I heard it, a number of years after the record came out. When I read the liner notes about the song, it blew me away.)
Noelani Mahoe and Ka’upena Wong then sang the song at the University of Hawai’i in 1964. Pete Seeger, a visiting artist and internationally renowned folksinger, was touched by the song’s haunting message and bright music. He asked that it be performed before an international group at a world folk music festival in Newport, Rhode Island.
During the ensuing decades, “Kaulana Na Pua” has been widely performed by Hawai’i’s most prominent singers and artists. In order to preserve the song’s subtext, which describes the feelings of dispossession and their resolve to stand firm, the artists have often included it on many recording documents, translating the kaona (hidden meaning) of the lyrics for those who might not be able to speak the language.
As a song of protest and resistance, Kaulana Na Pua seemed to come full circle during the Centennial observation of Queen Lili’uokalani’s overthrow which took place in 1993. Thousands gathered at the ‘Iolani Palace to sing this song.
Header picture credit: “Hawaiian Beach Stones” by Andrew via Flickr [CC BY 2.0]
SOME OTHER POSTS TO EXPLORE
(Click on each of the post titles below and see where it takes you….)
Thanks for your visit. I’d appreciate it if you would leave a note or comment below.
20 thoughts on “SONG OF PROTEST (Famous Are the Flowers)”
I love reading informed articles like this one. It reminds me of what I like to pass down to my own daughters who have Native American heritage (one Cherokee, the other Shawnee).
Sometimes it is a solemn reminder that the grass was never greener and we need to hold onto our ancestral roots to keep them from vanishing from the pages of history.
Protest songs are a great reminder of challenges a people group have endured. I believe they need to be preserved.
Thank you for being a part of that.
Thank you for your visit and for your comment. It is a truth that. Every people has suffered sorrow and pain at some point. The poems and the songs that survive are a way to remember this and to honor those who lived through those times.
Please do come again….
Hawaiian music is something I have only really experienced in the movies – Lilo & Stitch, Blue Hawaii and more recently The Lava Song played prior to Inside Out. It has a distinctive sound and you can feel the heart and soul in each song. Thank you for such a comprehensive post about this music and the history behind it. An enjoyable read.
Thanks for your visit and for taking the time to comment. I do appreciate it. Please do come again!
I’m a fan of poems and spoken words and I know when a poem is great. This one is. Hawaiians are famous with their songs that always talks about a story. Most Hawaiian songs are about a legend or a story of someone, especially the writer. The song of protest is a common song among Hawaiians.
Thanks for the visit and for sharing your thoughts, Dhayours. I do appreciate it.
Please do come again….
Thanks for this wonderful and comprehensive article. The ancient Hawaiian songs seems to be more than just songs with great messages and inspiration.
This is unlike the contemporary songs we hear nowadays. I do hope that the Hawaiian songs can be translated into English language and other very popular languages so that others can listen and inspired.
Thanks for your visit and for sharing your thoughts, AbiodunS.
The Hawaiian language has made a big comeback and there are, again, many composers who are writing in it and who are expanding the definition of what “Hawaiian” music is. It is very exciting for us.
I’m glad you enjoyed the post.
Please do come again.
Wow this is really interesting! It is amazing to see how culture and music are so deeply intertwined. It is also interesting to read about the history of Hawaii and how the natives felt about the whole experience along with how they expressed their feeling through song.
What platforms have this music on them? And how do I find them?
Wilson, thanks for your visit and for sharing your thoughts.
One of the best online sources for Hawaiian music is Mele.com. Check them out….
And do come again.
Such a comprehensive article! I have always loved Hawaiian music and the video is a great addition to your site.
We’ve been to Hawaii many times and there is a special place in my heart for the culture. Not everyone is going to find the topic interesting, but a large portion will.
The site itself is very clean an pleasing, nice graphics!
Emma, thank you for your visit and for sharing your thoughts. I’m glad you enjoyed the post. It’s a story that is dear to my heart and the video features several master musicians who are no longer with us.
Please do come again.
I love reading informative and educational posts like this one,
I believe it is very important that we remember our roots and traditions, and also respect the roots and traditions of other peoples and cultures,
I also believe that poetry is the perfect way to express ones feelings, especially if it needs to be done in a meaningful way.
Russ, thank you for your visit and for sharing your thoughts. Of course, I agree. I’m pleased you enjoyed the post.
Please come again.
WOW, great article!
Learned a lot about Hawaiian music…I am not familiar with The Stone-Eating Song language. but it sounds really great and native…The back story of this song is really incredible and historical.
Poetry has the power to cure people’s hearts.
I love to learn more about this kind of story. I really enjoyed this post. Keep it up and good luck!
Gihan, thanks for the visit and for sharing your thoughts. It is a truth that poetry and music heal hearts.
Please do come again.
Thank you for this wonderful and informative article. I really like History of any type, and it was a joy to read this, even if I know very little of Hawaiian History.
I’ve seen the video and the music is great, so … wonderfully hawaian 🙂 doesn’t seem like a protest song, but I guess you can protest in a very positive joyful way.
I liked this article enough that made me browse a bit your blog and website. Read and got really hooked by your corona-virus/pandemy article, and I totally see my thoughts reflected in your article. My biggest fear is that we learn nothing from this whole experience…
Keep up the good work with this blog!!
Thanks for your visit and for sharing your thoughts, Sophia. I’m very pleased that you were moved to explore my site more. Great!
It really does seem that the lessons are coming at us hot and heavy these days. We’ll keep on keeping on. Humans are good at that.
Please do come again.
Thanks for the article. I spent two years on Oahu back in the naughts and I wish I would have been able to learn a little more history of the islands.
One of my coworkers married a local gal whose family was very traditional. I remember they had some dancing and some sort of prayers in the local language during their ceremony and traditional Hawaiian foods mixed with “mainland” dishes during the reception.
I, of course, went to a few museums while on the island. The Hawaiian culture was truly amazing.
I’m glad the post brought back good memories for you, William.
Please do come again.